A Case on Dismissal for Refusing a Pay Cut

25th October 2011
A Case on Dismissal for Refusing a Pay Cut image

A Case on Dismissal for Refusing a Pay Cut

Frequently, especially in current economic conditions, Employers will want to know if they can cut costs by reducing the wages of its staff.  There is no hard and fast answer but a recent Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) decision in Garside and Laycock Limited –v- Booth gave some guidance for Employers in this situation.

Here Garside and Laycock Limited sought to avoid redundancies by cutting its work force’s salary by 5%.  Booth refused to accept the pay cut, and was dismissed as a result.  He claimed unfair dismissal, which the Employment Tribunal initially upheld upon the basis that it was reasonable for him to maintain his pay and conditions.  His employers appealed.

The EAT held that the Tribunal at first instance had erred in law.  Firstly it had wrongly considered the reasonableness of the Employee’s decision to reject the pay cut rather than whether the Employer was reasonable to dismiss the Employee for not accepting it.  Secondly the Tribunal had wrongly considered whether or not a dismissal for refusing a pay cut was fair depended upon whether or not the Employer was so desperate that the only way of salvaging the business was to propose cuts in pay and conditions.

The EAT sent the case back to the Tribunal for a fresh hearing, but gave guidance on the correct approach.  It said that the Tribunal must look at the circumstances (including the size and resources of the Employer) to see if it was reasonable to treat the refusal to agree a contractual variation as sufficient to dismiss the Employee.  At the same time the Tribunal should consider whether the dismissal was made in “accordance with equity”.  The EAT felt that this may be relevant if a management proposed to cut its own workers’ pay but not its own.  Similarly the process by which a pay cut was negotiated may be relevant where a Tribunal considers that it runs contrary to equity’s sense of fair dealing.

Daven Naghen, head of the Employment Team, commented as follows:-

“Dismissing an employee for refusing a pay cut or contractual variation is often a tricky issue.  If an employer is going to do this fairly, then it must be reasonable in the circumstances to treat the refusal of the employee as sufficient to dismiss.  If for example a pay cut is proposed, the management have agreed to take a pay cut, the pay cut is necessary in order to keep the business afloat and the staff were involved in a consultation process – then there is a reasonable chance that a dismissal of an employee in these circumstances for refusing the pay cut may be fair.  Each case will depend upon its own circumstances and no employer should ever dismiss an employee for refusal to accept a contractual variation without first seeking legal advice.”

If you require advice on this matter then please contact either Daven Naghen on 01775 722261, daven.naghen@maplessolicitors.com or at 23 New Road, Spalding, Lincolnshire PE11 1DH or Gemma Mayer on 01775 722261, gemma.mayer@maplessolicitors.com or at 23 New Road, Spalding, Lincolnshire PE11 1DH.

Maples supporting Macmillan Coffee Morning image

Maples supporting Macmillan Coffee Morning

On 29th September 2017 Maples Solicitors LLP will be hosting a coffee morning as part of Macmillan’s “World’s Biggest Coffee Morning”.

Tea, coffee and cakes will be served from 10:00am until 1:00pm and all donations received will go to Macmillan Cancer Support to assist them with providing medical, emotional, practical and financial support to those facing cancer and their families.

At the same time, Maples will also be running a free Wills, Lasting Powers of Attorney and Probate clinic so that whilst you are in the office you may take the opportunity to discuss any of these with one of the Private Client Team with no obligation to commit. You can use the time to raise any questions you may have about making a Will, who you could appoint as Executors, whether you need a Power of Attorney or how a Power of Attorney works, for example.

Maples hope to see their existing clients join them for the coffee morning and very much look forward to meeting new people- everyone is welcome!

If you would like to discuss any matters in relation to Wills, Lasting Powers of Attorney or any Probate related matters prior to the coffee morning then please contact one of the lawyers in our private client team:-

Jane Mawer- jane.mawer@maplessolicitors.com
Jamie Dobbs- jamie.dobbs@maplessolicitors.com
Faye Blair- faye.blair@maplessolcitors.com

Or telephone the office on 01775 722261 and ask to speak with one of the team.

Read More


Gemma Mayer LLB

"I would highly recommend Maples Solicitors, especially Gemma Mayer, for any conveyancing work. The level of support and professionalism was excellent at all times. I also felt if I needed to ask or clarify anything that it was not an issue. Buying and selling a house is stressful enough, but Gemma helped me through it step by step."

Anita Toal LLB BA

"I think you are brilliant. You can use my comments above. You are efficient, friendly and quite clearly very good at what you do. Mainly you don’t leave people hanging around too long for." "So easy to talk to her and she understood what I wanted. She put me at ease and I cant thank her enough"

Daven Naghen LLB

"I felt the service I got from Maples was excellent and was very honest all through the process. I would recommend Maples as a first class Solicitors group"

Faye Blair LLB

Faye was excellent, sensitive and acted very well to the time constraints we faced. Great service and dealt with compassion at such sad times made the process less painful very professional.

Jamie Dobbs ACILEx

Over the last forty years I have cause to deal with many law firms both in a personal and professional capacity, including some ‘top’ London Companies. In all of those dealings I have never found anyone as proactive and so willing to offer help and advice as Jamie Dobbs. During the last two years Jamie guided my parents through the completion of Lasting Powers of Attorney. Helped myself with the use of the LPA and recently dealing with Probate and Estate Administration following their death.

Mike Pepper MA

This is the second time we have used Mike Pepper at Maples Solicitors in the sale of our house. We cannot praise Mike enough for the highly efficient and professional service that he has provided us with. He is by far the best solicitor we have ever worked with, and the service that he has provided us with has gone far and beyond anything we have ever experienced. We have found the whole process to be a very relaxing experience.

Claire Smith FCILEx

Claire Smith has been amazing in every way. I highly recommend her and I am so grateful for all her help. She’s professional on all levels, reliable, extremely organised and I will be recommending her to everyone. I’m very lucky to have had her representing me and I can’t thank her enough. She is an asset to Maples. Thanks so much Claire!

Anita Zaborniak

We found it a pleasure to deal with Anita Zaborniak, she was most helpful and informative and kept us up to date with the progress of the purchase of our new home. If we were to move again we wouldn’t hesitate to use Maples again.