Telling lies does not necessarily invalidate Insur

25th July 2016
Telling lies does not necessarily invalidate Insur image

Telling lies does not necessarily invalidate Ins.

Introduction

It has long been established in English law that an insured cannot successfully claim from an insurer where the insured’s claim has been fabricated or dishonestly exaggerated.  This is known as the Fraudulent Claims Rule (“the FCR”).  Obviously the FCR was designed to deter fraud.  However on the 20th July 2017 the Supreme Court, the highest court in the United Kingdom, considered a more recent extension of the FCR to “collateral lies” which are lies told by the insured to embellish the claim but which are irrelevant because the claim is justified whether the statement is true or not.

An example of a “collateral lie” being the insured producing a false receipt for a stolen computer worth £1,000 when the computer has been stolen and is actually worth £1,000.

The Supreme Court held, by 4 judges to 1, in Versloot Dredging BV and Another v HDI Gerling Industrie Versicherung AG and Others that the FCR does not apply to “collateral lies” which are immaterial to the insured’s right to recover.

The Versloot Case

The insured’s boat had been damaged beyond repair by a peril of the seas, namely very inclement weather.  The insured presented a claim to its insurers for a sum in excess of €3 million claiming that the crew had heard the bilge alarm but could not investigate because the vessel was rolling in heavy waters.  This was a lie but it was irrelevant to the claim since it was found that a peril of the seas had caused the loss.  Initially the courts held that the lie was a “fraudulent device” which did mean that the insurers did not have to pay out under the policy.

The Supreme Court however held that the FCR did not apply to “collateral lies” as the lie was immaterial and irrelevant to the honest claim.  The loss was caused by the bad weather and as such the lie was irrelevant.

Conclusions

Daven Naghen head of our Dispute Resolution Team has commented on the case as follows:-

“This ruling does distinguish between on the one hand fraudulent claims which are fabricated or dishonestly exaggerated, and valid claims supported by irrelevant lies or embellished evidence.  In the latter these false statements stand to gain nothing more for the insured beyond what it is legally due.  I do think that this is a victory for common sense.  However I would continue to encourage persons to be entirely frank and honest with insurers in such circumstances, since in particular if the lie is deemed material to the claim then there is a very strong chance that the claim will be rightly rejected by the insurer.  In particular inflating the value of an otherwise genuine claim still remains fraud and is likely to lead to a rejection of the claim.”

If you require advice on an insurance claim then please contact Daven Naghen on 01775 722261 or email daven.naghen@maplessolicitors.com or arrange an appointment or visit our offices at 23 New Road, Spalding, Lincolnshire, PE11 1DH.


Free Wills Month in October image

Free Wills Month in October

Maples are pleased to announce that they are taking part in Free Wills Month throughout October. If you are aged 55 or over you can make your Will for free and have the opportunity to help one or more of the sponsoring charities in the process. Appointments are limited in number and are allocated on a first come first served basis.

For further details please contact a member of our Wills and Probate Department:-

Jane Mawer- jane.mawer@maplessolicitors.com
Jamie Dobbs- jamie.dobbs@maplessolicitors.com
Faye Blair- faye.blair@maplessolcitors.com

Or telephone the office 01775 722261 and ask to speak with one of the team.

Read More

Testimonials

Gemma Mayer LLB

"I would highly recommend Maples Solicitors, especially Gemma Mayer, for any conveyancing work. The level of support and professionalism was excellent at all times. I also felt if I needed to ask or clarify anything that it was not an issue. Buying and selling a house is stressful enough, but Gemma helped me through it step by step."

Anita Toal LLB BA

"I think you are brilliant. You can use my comments above. You are efficient, friendly and quite clearly very good at what you do. Mainly you don’t leave people hanging around too long for." "So easy to talk to her and she understood what I wanted. She put me at ease and I cant thank her enough"

James Turner BA

James Turner was extremely helpful with our buying process. Everything went smoothly. We are very happy with the level of professionalism demonstrated by the office. Highly recommended solicitors. Will definitely do business with them again.

Daven Naghen LLB

"Daven provided an excellent service, from attending the first interview with me to the final court appearance. He filled me full of confidence that he would defend me to which he did and come out with an excellent outcome in view of my position that I had put myself in."

Faye Blair LLB

Faye was excellent, sensitive and acted very well to the time constraints we faced. Great service and dealt with compassion at such sad times made the process less painful very professional.

Jamie Dobbs ACILEx

Over the last forty years I have cause to deal with many law firms both in a personal and professional capacity, including some ‘top’ London Companies. In all of those dealings I have never found anyone as proactive and so willing to offer help and advice as Jamie Dobbs. During the last two years Jamie guided my parents through the completion of Lasting Powers of Attorney. Helped myself with the use of the LPA and recently dealing with Probate and Estate Administration following their death.

Mike Pepper MA

Mike Pepper gave us excellent advice. He was always most helpful and accommodating giving lucid explanations every step of the way. Thank you Mike.

Donna Sandison FCILEx

Donna has been helpful and professional every step of the way during the process. Always on hand to answer any queries and totally professional and friendly at all times.